My 7yo son has been hitting everyone lately. I'm assuming it's lately, but who knows if it's just now he's getting caught. There are 3 "issues" with this. First, the phone call from school. Second is the sleepover, snow day visitor, and computer game influence. Third is the punishment.
The phone call from his teacher couldn't have come at a better time. My husband and I were driving back from a nice day in Portland, very relaxed and energized. I heard the information on voice mail first because my phone didn't actually ring. Which is good because it gave me time to process. It takes me a little bit of time to think things through. In the past I would have reacted in some form of shock, denial, anger, shame, etc, but in keeping with my New Year's Resolutions I remained calm. I returned the phone call and got the news that he's been sent to Student Support two times in three days for hitting. The teacher didn't actually see the incidents and was simply relaying information. Since it happened on the playground, we concluded with a "boys will be boys" summation. But that's pretty much what I've vowed to never accept in raising my boys to be respectful.
I told my husband all the news. His quick response was "No more sleepovers. No more computer." I didn't agree. I know that the chaos earlier in the week from playing with 2 wild friends has greatly influenced his latest behavior, but taking away privileges doesn't address the problem. He's always going to have wild friends in his life so I'd rather he learn from the experience earlier than later. And I will always have to contend with the computer so that too needs to be addressed rather than taken away. I want to know why he thinks it's acceptable to hit someone and if he can come up with a better way to handle his frustration. I'm learning to accept that males will always be in some sort of power struggle but I don't think it's okay to act out when the mood strikes. When I catch my son "wrestling" with his friends in the house it makes me nuts. Go outside! There's a time and a place for everything and the living room is not one of them. And sneaking a punch at your little brother for whatever reason simply is not acceptable. So now I just need to figure out how to change this. I'm pretty sure it's not going to happen in one week.
When my 7yo got home from school I asked the usual "How was your day?" not sure what to expect. He actually mentioned the Student Support incident but was a little defensive. "It wasn't my fault," he immediately added. I replied "Fault, or no fault, you don't hit anyone. It's about respecting other people's boundaries." Try explaining that to a 7yo. He looked at my cross-eyed. "Honey, it's like this: When you force your feelings or in your case your fist on someone, you're bulldozing them. Um, you're plowing them over as it they're dirt and not human." He seemed to understand. I continued, "On the other hand, if someone came after you with a fist, I wouldn't expect you to just stand there and take it. What do you think would be the best thing to do?" "Hit him back," he replied. "Try again," I said. "Tell an adult," he said. "Well, that's good but isn't there a middle ground?" Oops, I had to explain middle ground. "Isn't there one more option, like using words?" I asked. "I would tell him to stop it and walk away," he replied. Bingo. Now how do I ingrain this in his brain?
And now the punishment. When I asked my son what he thought his punishment should be he said to ground him. I said no way, I want you outside and active as much as possible. You're not going to hide out in your room. We decided to add a "Show Respect" button to his chore chart. It's been up before but it's time to revisit.
Actually, the onus of the punishment is on me. I've been lazy. I need to limit sleepovers, lay out the rules to both boys when friends come over, keep the time structured, and supervise them better. I also need to enforce computer time rules. I came up with a good solution that I snuck in the next day, so as to deflect from actually being a punishment. Upon completion of the chore chart each week the boys get "daddy bucks" which they can redeem at half value for whatever they want or full value if it goes into their savings. From now on, when they want to play on the computer it costs one daddy buck for a half-hour. Another way to give them choices.